EA Loot Boxes ‘Not Gambling,’ Canadian Judge Rules

Must read


Posted on: March 23, 2023, 10:32h. 

Last updated on: March 23, 2023, 01:44h.

A Canadian judge has rejected claims that the loot boxes employed by video games publisher EA constitute gambling.

EA, loot boxes, British Columbia, Madden NFL
Loot boxes for sale in the Madden NFL series of games, which sparked the lawsuit. EA argues that nothing in its games constitutes gambling, and a BC judge agrees. (Image: EA)

Judge Justice Margot Fleming of British Columbia’s Supreme Court said that gambling must involve the risk of losing or gaining something of real-world value, which was absent in EA’s video games.

Unlike a casino chip, virtual currency and virtual items in loot boxes can never be ‘cashed out’ to gain money,” Fleming wrote.

However, she ruled that a class-action lawsuit against the games company could proceed. This was based on the complaint that EA’s loot boxes may have adopted “deceptive acts or practices.”

Risk and Reward

A loot box is a consumable, in-game item that offers players randomized chances to win virtual items or skills that may be necessary for player advancement through the game. While they occur naturally within the game, players can often use real cash to buy in-game currency to splurge on loot boxes. The element of chance and reward mechanisms involved have long drawn comparisons to gambling.

The plaintiff in the lawsuit, Mark Sutherland, bought loot boxes in the Madden NFL series of games. But the class action extends to anyone in British Columbia who paid for loot boxes in any of EA’s games. This covers around 70 titles, including the FIFA series.

The lawsuit argued that loot boxes and their virtual items had “intrinsic value” because they could be sold on third-party platforms. The judge found this to be false, noting they could only be traded on EA’s own auction platform in return for virtual currency.

“Consequently, there is no prospect of gaining, or losing, anything with a real-world value through the defendants’ in-house auctions,” Fleming wrote.

EA said in a statement: “We’re pleased that the trial court rejected, as a matter of law, the allegations of unlawful gaming. The court’s decision reaffirms our position that nothing in our games constitutes gambling.”

Banned in Belgium

The judge’s decision largely echoes legal rulings elsewhere on the nature of loot boxes and gambling. So far, Belgium and the Netherlands are the only jurisdictions to have banned loot boxes for contravening their gambling laws.

A federal judge in Washington State ruled in 2018 that the virtual currencies used in social casinos could be said to have real-world value, which could have ramifications for the video games industry there.

Sutherland’s suit will proceed on claims of deceptive practices. These include allegations that EA misleads players about the odds of winning rare and valuable items while encouraging players to make real-money purchases.

Fortnite developer Epic Games recently agreed to pay the US Federal Trade Commission a record $520 million to settle deceptive practices claims. These included duping players into making unwanted in-game purchases and violating children’s privacy.

A proposed class-action suit was filed against Epic Games in the BC Supreme Court last Friday.


Source link

More articles

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest article

kemampuan spesial putaran ajaib slot mahjong ways 1 langsung cuan maksimalteknik keramat slot mahjong ways 2 auto turun scatter berlimpahslot jackpot unlimited paling di cari memberslot sugar rush 1000 mudah jackpot besartrik menangkan jackpot pakai strategi inirahasia mengalahkan mesin slot onlinertp dan volatilitas slot pragmatic gates of olympus hari inicara kerja fitur free spin pada slot gates of olympusakun vip mesin slot kakek zeus mudah dapat x500 tiap spincara menang slot sensasional hanya modal receh khusus slot olympusslot unlimited scatter tanpa batas game slot olympus 1000 terbarulink slot gacor terbaru saat inislot demo x500 mesin slot gate of gatotkaca hokiakun pro server jepang jaminan sensa slot olympus x500slot pasti menang dijamin perkalian besar pasti muncul gacor bangetslot anti kalah prediksi admin indra kenzrahasia bocoran dari ahli slot starlight princessstrategi meraih kemenangan besar sweet bonanza x100mengenal simbol penting pada slot gates of olympusfitur multiplikator dari slot gates of olympus yang harus kamu taucara jitu melipat gandakan kemenangan bermain slot onlineslot mahjong ways 2 scatter hitam membararahasia mengalahkan kunci admin mesin slot olympuspanduan lengkap cara mudah jp slot mahjong waysslot maxwin pasti jackpotpola hoki slot super mahjong ways 2 jaminan maxwin sekali spintrik ledakan bom besar x100 sweet bonanzacara mudah munculkan fitur slot scatter hitam kemenangan maksimalcara jitu mengalahkan bandar judi online dengan main slot pragmatic playsistem kemenangan besar 100 juta main slot mahjong ways banjir wild terbanyakcara menjadi sultan dalam sekejap bermain slot mahjong ways2rahasia gacor link maxwin terbaru pgsoftmain slot online dengan pola hoki dijamin maxwinslot mahjong lagi bagi bagi jackpot tanpa batas hanya butuh modal recehkunci kemenangan slot mahjong waysrahasia jam gacor gampang jackpot slot mahjong pandakumpulan slot gacor terbaru 2024sistem spin ajaib slot mahjong ways 1 gampang kasi kemenangan instantcheat gacor slot onlineslot scatter hitam menggila langsung menang 100 jutaslot rave party fever menang maxwin dengan trik bocoran ampuhpola jitu main ikan gampang menang slot koi gate habanerodaftar slot paling jitu memberikan kemenangan kepada member barubocoran pola sakti slot gates of olympuscara mendapatkan perkalian tidak wajar slot mahjong waysbocoran terbaru ahli bermain slot onlinealasan mengapa slot pragmatic gates of olympus begitu populerbocoran pola slot gates of olympus yang pasti slot hokibermain slot pragmatic gates of olympus dengan modal minimtrik main slot jackpot modal recehbocoran akurat sekali spin slot mahjong ways superbanjir kemenangan konsisten slot mahjong tanpa ampun kasi jackpotcara terbaik memaksimalkan kemenangan bermain slot mahjong ways 2admin putri bagi bagi akun sakti khusus slot pragmatic playpenemuan jam hoki slot gacorcara bermain slot gacor dengan langkah ajaib dari admin stevenulasan mendalam starlight princess x1000 menurut para ahliperbandingan slot starlight princess dengan slot lainnya di tahun 2024keistimewaan akun vip di slot online server thailandstrategi terbaik untuk menang di slot starlight princess dari pragmatic playfakta bocoran pola scatter dari negeri para princessgrebek situs pola gacor zeus untuk turunkan scatterketimpa scatter x1000 membuat bandar mahjong ways gulung tikarkumpulan naga hitam memecahkan pola gacor di mahjong wayslari bersama kakek zeus mengejar maxwin x1000mandi jackpot bareng di situs gacor anti rungkad bonanzapeluang kemudahan mencuri pola kakek merah zeusspenjual rujak memberi pola buah untuk mendapatkan jackpot di bonanzaresiko jadi admin slot dapat memecahkan pola gacor mahjong ways2seorang pria muda di temukan sukses berkat pola gacor princessnya