/** * dev demo deploy */ //dev demo or none if (!defined('TD_DEPLOY_MODE')) { define("TD_DEPLOY_MODE", 'deploy'); } do_action( 'tdc_header' ); if ( has_action( 'tdc_header' ) ) { return; } ?>

German Gaming Operators Out of Luck in Fights With States

Must read

[ad_1]

Posted on: July 20, 2023, 07:44h. 

Last updated on: July 20, 2023, 11:25h.

Administrative courts in Germany are demonstrating that European Union (EU) laws don’t trump local ones. Two courts, one in Berlin and another in Düsseldorf, have rejected claims by gambling operators that tried to argue that local legislation violates established EU protocols.

The Reichstag building in Berlin, home to the country's Parliament
The Reichstag building in Berlin, home to the country’s Parliament. German states are rejecting claims by gambling operators about distancing rules. (Image: Flickr)

In both cases, the crux of the dispute centered on the required distance needed between gaming properties. While the plaintiffs in the lawsuits weren’t identified, the outcome extends across the entire gaming spectrum.

This isn’t the first time a gaming operator has tried to claim that German laws infringed on EU laws. However, the response of both courts makes it clear that the country’s legal system is going to play by its own rules.

Berlin Holds Its Ground

The statutory minimum distance between sports betting agencies and existing gambling arcades in the state of Berlin is 500 meters (1,640 feet). This is in accordance with how the state moved forward with its gambling laws after the implementation of the Fourth State Treaty on Gambling.

With reference to this provision, the State Office for Citizens and Regulatory Affairs (LABO, for its German acronym) has rejected numerous applications from betting operators. They had sought to operate betting shops where this distance to existing gambling halls would otherwise be less than this.

The operators have tried to get Berlin to change its stance. On the one hand, they argue the permits granted to the respective gaming hall under the Gaming Hall Act and the State Treaty on Gambling are valid. Additionally, they want LABO to grant the respective betting agent permits to operate.

In particular, they refer to the fact that the minimum distances aren’t required for the protection of minors and players. They are also unconstitutional and contrary to European law, and leave sportsbooks at a disadvantage compared to the gaming halls, which were already operational before the new laws took effect.

There’s also a caveat that no two betting shops can be within 2,000 meters (6,561 feet) of each other. This is to prevent an operator from monopolizing a particular area, and was also part of the legal battle launched by two unidentified companies.

Berlin’s 4th Chamber of the Administrative Court dismissed all complaints, according to a recent announcement. It determined that Berlin, because of the treaty, has the right to establish its gaming regime however it sees fit. The court also dismissed the actions for annulment of existing licenses as inadmissible because the betting operators lacked the necessary legal standing to request it.

Düsseldorf Echoes Berlin’s Position

In Düsseldorf, betting agencies must maintain a minimum distance of 350 meters (1,148 feet) from public schools and child and youth welfare facilities. This also took effect when the latest federal gambling treaty went live.

Betting operators tried to fight the state government here as well. However, just like in Berlin, they failed to present a convincing argument.

The Administrative Court of Düsseldorf, in a separate announcement, has confirmed that the rights of betting operators and betting brokers aren’t as important as the rights of consumers. The operators can’t argue that the laws violate EU legislation, nor can they assert that they are unconstitutional. Like Berlin, Düsseldorf interprets the gaming treaty to mean that the states can establish their own rules.

The operators can try for an appeal, which would have to go to the Higher Administrative Court for the State of North Rhine-Westphalia in Münster. Based on these rulings and others, the case isn’t likely to get far.

Gaming Regulator Commissions Research

Now that Germany’s new gambling treaty and its new regulator are in place, everyone is anxious to see how the industry is doing. It wasn’t until recently that online gaming and sports betting began in the country, and an assessment is needed.

The Joint Gaming Authority (GGL, for its German acronym) has commissioned a study to conduct that assessment. It has tapped Dr. Tobias Hayer of the University of Bremen’s Institute for Public Health and Nursing Research to take the lead.

The goal of the research is to find out how well the new treaty is working, and if responsible gambling solutions are effective. The GGL didn’t indicate when the research will conclude, but explained that it expects to conduct a “comprehensive evaluation” of the treaty’s effectiveness in 2026.

[ad_2]

Source link

More articles

Latest article

Ibu Rahmi Penjual Nasi Uduk Di Lohbener Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Jam Ganjil Pak Jatmiko Petani Di Karangampel Dapat Rp185 Juta Dari Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Sumarni Karyawan Warung Pasekan Auto Saldo Naik Berkat Mahjong Anak Kosan Di Balongan Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Setelah Main Jam 03 33 Ibu Nining Pkl Desa Sliyeg Menang Rp190 Juta Dari Mahjong Ways 2 Pak Darto Tukang Las Jatibarang Kena Hoki Subuh Main Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Hastuti Guru Ngaji Di Kroya Dapat Kejutan Scatter Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Yuyun Pedagang Keliling Kertasemaya Tembus Jp Di Mahjong Ways 2 Pak Ruslan Pengantar Barang Gabuswetan Bisa Beli Motor Dari Mahjong Ibu Eni Warung Sarapan Di Bangodua Dapat Multiplier Gila Mahjong Ways Cara Warga Medan Bisa Dapat Transferan Jutaan Dari Mahjong Ways Trik Anak Kos Surabaya Menang Mahjong Ways Hanya Dalam 5 Menit Panduan Lengkap Main Mahjong Ways Sampai Cair Ke Rekening Tips Menangkan Jackpot Mahjong Ways Dengan Modal Kecil Cara Cepat Spin Mahjong Ways Biar Transferan Gak Berhenti Rahasia Pemuda Bandung Auto Cuan Dari Mahjong Ways Tutorial Main Mahjong Ways Supaya Saldo Rekening Naik Tiap Hari Begini Cara Guru Ngawi Menang Rp20 Juta Lewat Mahjong Ways Strategi Mahjong Ways Untuk Pemula Biar Langsung Jp Cara Ibu Rumah Tangga Di Lampung Bisa Menang Mahjong Ways Ibu Murni Pedagang Pasar Di Lohbener Tembus Rp170 Juta Lewat Mahjong Pak Ridwan Kuli Pasar Kroya Dapat Hoki Digital Dari Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Lestari Warung Sarapan Di Jatibarang Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Subuh Anak Warnet Di Balongan Main Mahjong Ways 2 Pukul 01 30 Dan Menang Ibu Rahmah Penjual Gorengan Di Sliyeg Auto Hepi Dapat Mahjong Ways 2 Pak Tegar Pengantar Galon Kertasemaya Kena Hoki Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Rukmini Pkl Di Pasekan Dapat Rp162 Juta Dari Mahjong Ways 2 Pak Bambang Tukang Parkir Bangodua Bisa Beli Hp Baru Dari Mahjong Ibu Dian Ibu Rumah Tangga Gabuswetan Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Jam Ganjil Pak Andika Penjaga Kebun Di Juntinyuat Tembus Jp Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Sari Penjual Kue Di Kroya Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Saat Hujan Deras Pak Sugeng Petani Lohbener Dapat Rp193 Juta Berkat Scatter Mahjong Ibu Nurhayati Warga Balongan Auto Saldo Naik Berkat Mahjong Ways 2 Anak Kosan Di Sliyeg Main Mahjong Ways 2 Subuh Dan Tembus Jp Ibu Rina Guru Honorer Kertasemaya Dapat Hoki Lewat Simbol Emas Mahjong Pak Jamal Kuli Pasar Jatibarang Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Jam Ganjil Ibu Umamah Pkl Pasekan Dapat Kejutan Digital Dari Mahjong Ways 2 Pemuda Bangodua Main Mahjong Ways 2 Dan Bisa Beli Laptop Baru Ibu Misnah Warung Makan Gabuswetan Dapat Rp185 Juta Dari Mahjong Pak Hamid Sopir Truk Juntinyuat Kaget Lihat Saldo Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Tinuk Pedagang Keliling Di Lohbener Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Saat Subuh Pak Rahmat Petani Pasekan Dapat Rp188 Juta Dari Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Lilis Penjual Sarapan Di Karangampel Auto Hepi Berkat Mahjong Anak Warnet Cikedung Dapat Kejutan Scatter Beruntun Di Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Sutinah Pkl Di Bangodua Pulang Bawa Rp175 Juta Dari Mahjong Pak Darto Penjaga Gudang Di Kroya Tembus Jp Mahjong Ways 2 Jam Aneh Ibu Hamidah Ibu Rumah Tangga Jatibarang Dapat Hoki Digital Mahjong Pak Usman Kuli Bangunan Sliyeg Bisa Beli Sepeda Motor Dari Mahjong Ibu Sriatun Penjual Pecel Di Gabuswetan Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Dinihari Mahasiswi Juntinyuat Main Mahjong Ways 2 Sambil Belajar Dan Menang Ibu Sukarni Pedagang Pasar Di Lohbener Dapat Rp180 Juta Dari Mahjong Pak Tarjo Petani Kroya Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Jam Ganjil Dinihari Ibu Ratna Guru Paudd Di Balongan Auto Saldo Naik Karena Mahjong Anak Kosan Jatibarang Dapat Hoki Lewat Multiplier Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Nurlela Pkl Pasekan Dapat Kejutan Digital Dari Mahjong Ways 2 Pak Jumadi Kuli Proyek Di Sliyeg Bisa Renovasi Dapur Karena Mahjong Ibu Eni Warung Sarapan Kertasemaya Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Pagi Hari Pemuda Bangodua Main Mahjong Ways 2 Subuh Dan Bisa Beli Hp Baru Ibu Sumiatun Warga Gabuswetan Dapat Rp173 Juta Berkat Mahjong Pak Salim Tukang Parkir Juntinyuat Kaget Lihat Jp Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Warti Pedagang Bumbu Di Kroya Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Saat Subuh Pak Sugeng Petani Di Lohbener Bawa Pulang Rp190 Juta Dari Mahjong Ibu Sulastri Penjual Sarapan Di Balongan Tembus Jp Mahjong Ways 2 Anak Warnet Jatibarang Main Mahjong Ways 2 Dan Menang Besar Jam Ganjil Ibu Nurjanah Pkl Pasekan Auto Saldo Naik Berkat Mahjong Ways 2 Pak Hasan Kuli Angkut Bangodua Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Di Hari Libur Ibu Rahmah Guru Ngaji Sliyeg Dapat Kejutan Scatter Mahjong Ways 2 Mahasiswa Karangampel Dapat Rp185 Juta Berkat Multiplier Mahjong Ibu Sutini Penjual Jajanan Kertasemaya Dapat Hoki Digital Mahjong Pak Eko Sopir Truk Gabuswetan Dapat Simbol Emas Mahjong Ways 2 Bapak Petugas Parkir Di Pasar Rawa Beras Ikut Mahjong Ways 2 Saat Hujan Gerimis Mantan Kuli Pindahan Di Kediri Temukan Polanya Sendiri Di Mahjong Ways 2 Penjaga Biliard Malam Di Kroya Bingung Sendiri Lihat Putaran Mahjong Ways 2 Tukang Ketok Mobil Di Galeri Pasuruan Hening Usai Lihat Mahjong Ways 2 Jalan Istri Pedagang Tahu Di Cisaat Duduk Sunyi Saat Lihat Hasil Mahjong Ways 2 Pria Pemotong Ayam Di Jombang Diam Tak Bersuara Saat Mahjong Wins 1 Berputar Nenek Penjual Kerupuk Di Pinggir Danau Melongo Lihat Mahjong Wins 1 Beraksi Asisten Tukang Cukur Pasar Senen Bicara Sendiri Sambil Main Mahjong Wins 1 Wanita Pembungkus Kue Basah Di Garut Terdiam Lihat Mahjong Wins 1 Menyala Petugas Penarik Gerobak Sayur Di Bekasi Ngepau Di Mahjong Wins 1 Malam Itu Ibu Nuraini Pkl Di Cikedung Menang Rp182 Juta Berkat Mahjong Ways 2 Pak Hamid Petani Sukagumiwang Auto Hepi Dapat Jp Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Sriatun Pedagang Keliling Pasekan Tembus Multiplier Mahjong Anak Kosan Lohbener Main Mahjong Ways 2 Pukul 02 11 Dan Menang Besar Ibu Hj Marni Guru Ngaji Di Balongan Dapat Hoki Lewat Mahjong Ways Pak Rudi Kuli Pasar Juntinyuat Bisa Beli Hp Baru Dari Mahjong Ways 2 Ibu Eni Warung Nasi Di Jatibarang Kaget Lihat Saldo Mahjong Naik Mahasiswi Kroya Main Mahjong Ways 2 Sambil Belajar Dan Tembus Jp Ibu Wulan Penjual Kue Di Kertasemaya Dapat Scatter Beruntun Mahjong Pak Ramlan Sopir Angkot Gabuswetan Dapat Rp179 Juta Dari Mahjong Cara Wd Mahjong Ways Lewat Bomjitu Bomjitu Bikin Wd Jadi Gampang Main Di Bomjitu Auto Wd Mahjong Wd Setiap Hari Dari Mahjong Bomjitu Trik Wd Mahjong Paling Cepat Di Bomjitu Bomjitu Tempat Wd Mahjong Ways Tercepat Maen Mahjong Wd Cepet Pakai Bomjitu Wd Gampang Lewat Bomjitu Mahjong Bomjitu Rahasia Wd Mahjong Ways Cara Cepat Wd Slot Mahjong Di Bomjitu Lansia Penyortir Sampah Di Sleman Kaget Usai Angka Mahjong Ways 2 Turun Penuh Rekan Tukang Pengecat Rumah Di Subang Diam Tak Berkata Saat Mahjong Ways 2 Berputar Remaja Pengantar Galon Di Ciledug Terpaku Lihat Golden Pattern Mahjong Ways 2 Buruh Jahit Lepas Di Serang Gigit Jari Lalu Senyum Karena Mahjong Ways 2 Muncul Penjaga Parkir Malam Di Krian Gemetaran Saat Simbol Mahjong Ways 2 Berderet Kegabutan Siang Bikin Ezzar Main Mahjong Dan Menang Rp 12.300.000 Cerita Nadhifa Dapat Kejutan Dari Mahjong Saat Lagi Di Kereta Main Mahjong Di Teras Malam Hari Bikin Khaled Freespin 3x Tanpa Niat Serius Debby Malah Raih Rp 4.750.000 Dari Mahjong Fathan Nekat Main Mahjong Karena Diajak Teman Akhirnya Menang Ibu Rahma Pedagang Kue Pagi Di Pasekan Menang Rp174 Juta Dari Mahjong Pak Salim Petani Lohbener Dapat Hoki Lewat Simbol Emas Mahjong Ways Ibu Santi Pkl Di Balongan Kaget Lihat Saldo Naik Main Mahjong Ways Anak Warnet Di Sliyeg Menang Jam 03 12 Karena Multiplier Mahjong Ibu Marsini Warga Juntinyuat Tembus Jp Dini Hari Dari Mahjong Ways Pak Rusdi Sopir Truk Kroya Auto Hepi Bawa Pulang Rp193 Juta Mahjong Ibu Lestari Penjaga Warung Jatibarang Dapat Kejutan Scatter Mahjong Pemuda Bangodua Main Mahjong Ways 2 Saat Subuh Dan Menang Besar Ibu Nurul Guru Paudd Di Kertasemaya Dapat Rp168 Juta Dari Mahjong Pak Jatmiko Kuli Angkut Cikedung Beli Motor Dari Mahjong Ways 2